Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon
“Ten Years After” Tasting Party of 2016 Cabernet Sauvignon Wines
We were invited to a unique wine tasting venue on Saturday at Tremayne’s Concetta Wine Shop in Modesto. Paul Tremayne hosted the event at his wine shop/wine tasting/office (in the process) and Rick Eason provided the wines from his cellar. There was a nominal charge for this event.
Photo ©Michael Kelly
The intent was to see how some very good wines held up over ten years. This was a blind tasting, and the wines were revealed at the conclusion of the event. This was a very interesting and informative tasting.
Photo ©Michael Kelly
Wines were priced from $75 to over $300 a bottle buying them today. Each participant had eight wines already poured for the first flight and then a second flight of six wines was poured. Everyone rated their two best wines from each flight and the worst one from all fourteen wines. A simple vote by a raised hand determined which were the winners and losers.
The top wines that held up the best, surprisingly were not the most expensive. Coming in first place was the Nth Degree by Wente Wines from Livermore at $95. Others rating top honors were Beringer Winery – Steinhauer Ranch, Berringer – Private Reserve, Seaver GTS – $220-$300, Selah – $135. All the wines were drinkable, but a few were “over their prime” and on a slippery slope downwards. Those included Mt Brave – $100-$150 95pts, Karl Lawrence Cellars $75-$85 94 pts, Faust $139, Silver Oak Cellars Napa Valley $150-$175, La Jota Winery $250 95 pts, Silver Oak Cellars Alexander Valley $150-$160, Gemstone $179 – 93 pts all receiving the lower scores.
The balance of wine “in the middle ratings” included Far Niente $170-$350, Seaver NLS Diamond Mtn, BV Georges De LaTour $140-$197.
Concluding the afternoon tasting was a treat of two Cabernet Sauvignon wines being 1996 wines and one 2006. The first was Dunn Vineyards from Howell Mtn and a 1996 Silver Oak Cellar Napa Valley. The third wine was a 2006 Berringer Private Reserve. By a show of hand, recorded Dunn Vineyards held up the best by an overwhelming majority.
Photo ©Michael Kelly
I very much appreciated attending this event and thank you Paul and Rick. Another mention should be for Tom Bender who coordinated this event.
Key take aways from this event are: 1) know how long to hold a wine 2) know how to store a wine for optimum enjoyment 3) price alone is not a criterion for longevity of a bottle.
Sláinte,
Michael Kelly
Super Bowl Weekend – Opened the MVP 2008 Casa Piena Cabernet Sauvignon from Napa Valley
Photo ©Michael Kelly
Background
Casa Piena is the winery founded by Carmen Policy who served as President and CEO of the San Francisco 49’ers from 1991 to 1997. Carmen was involved since 1981 , being friends with Eddie DeBarolo Jr in the executive leadership of the SF 49’ers. His legacy was instrumental in all five of the 49’ers Super Bowl winning teams.
Carmen and his wife lived in San Francisco permanently in 1991. Then later returned to Ohio for five years as President, CEO and part owner of the Cleveland Browns. They wanted to return to San Francisco and managed to move back in 2004. Seeking a change after twenty-five years in professional sports, then they decided to move to Napa Valley. Here they acquired the property in 2003 and planted 10 acres of Cabernet Sauvignon and Cabernet Franc in 2003. The first vintage produced was 2006.
Casa Piena translates to “full house” in Italian and was chosen to honor his five children.
The Wine – “Wine is bottled poetry” – Robert Louis Stevenson
Photo ©Michael Kelly
I originally purchased this wine in 2011 from a friend in Napa Valley who was selling wine for Carmen. Carmen hired renown winemaker Thomas Rivers Brown to produce the wines from his estate vineyard. The current vintage is 2023 and sells for $150/bottle.
First on the eyes a deep ruby and purple coloring with medium-heavy viscosity. Looking at the wine in the glass there is an opulent declaration that it is special. On the nose, fruits of blackberries and black cherries waft delightfully into the senses with floral notes. Once on the palate, this wine shows the “Super Bowl” pedigree of the fruits, along with blueberries and a lovely sweet vanilla pipe tobacco. Finally, at the finish, dusty earth traits combined with luxurious smooth and velvety tannins. The softness of the tannins was like wrapping up in front of the fireplace on a cold evening in a blanket, surrounding each sip.
Photo ©Michael Kelly
The initial assessment was rated 94 points and mentioned to drink before 2015. While it may have lost a little in the tannin structure, it was still an enjoyable bottle. The wine was originally aged 20 months in 80% new French oak and 100% Cabernet Sauvignon and came in at 14.7% alcohol.
The wine was double decanted and put back in the original bottle and allowed to breathe for two hours. This wine will make my annual list of Best Wines Tasted for 2026. Unfortunately, it was the last bottle in the cellar. I would like to taste a more current vintage as reports have stated the vineyard has matured to make some of the best grapes in Napa Valley.
The Food and Wine Pairing – “Food without wine is a corpse; wine without food is a ghost. United and well matched, they are as body and soul: living partners” – Andre Simon
Photo ©Michael Kelly
Pulled this wine this weekend in lieu of the Super Bowl. While the 49’ers, our team of choice, did not make the Super Bowl, thought it appropriate to enjoy this wine. Tonight’s menu was a new dish called Skirt Steak Marinade with Chimichurri Sauce. The ingredients for the marinade were olive oil, fresh squeezed orange juice, fresh squeezed lime juice, soy sauce, Worcestershire sauce, red wine vinegar, minced garlic, skirt steak with kosher salt and pepper to taste. The meat was allowed to marinate for 7 hours.
For the Chimichurri sauce, which was a new recipe and divine, the ingredients included fresh parsley, fresh cilantro, olive oil, diced onion, minced garlic, fresh lime juice, red wine vinegar, crushed red peppers kosher salt and black pepper. All the ingredients were blended in a food processor to form a thick sauce that was drizzled on the meat slices on the dish.
The meat was seared on the barbeque at 1500 degrees for about 4-5 minutes on each side.
Accompanied by cauliflower rice with onions and a modicum of Chimichurri sauce mixed in and fresh sauteed string beans in olive oil and garlic.
While we absolutely enjoyed the marinade and Chimichurri sauce immensely, we were a bit disappointed in the skirt steak toughness. We will endeavor the same recipe next time but substitute the meat with flank steak.
Sláinte,
Michael Kelly
2022 VJB Cellars Aglianico (Sonoma) and 2012 Entre Nous Cabernet Sauvignon (Napa) With A Delicious Meal
Photo ©Michael Kelly
Here is a previous review of the 2021 VJB Cellars Aglianico: https://californiawinesandwineries.com/2021/09/11/eureka-2017-vjb-cellars-estate-aglianico/
Photo ©Michael Kelly
This entire meal was enjoyed with a 2012 Entre Nous Cabernet Sauvignon along with the Aglianico. For a review of this exquisite wine made by Philip Melka that unfortunately is no longer made, can be found at: https://californiawinesandwineries.com/2023/01/03/2009-entre-nous-cabernet-sauvignon-what-a-great-wine/
We started out with various cheeses, crackers and roasted almonds. Additionally, a combination of gourmet potato chips from WINE CHIPS were enjoyed. The WINE CHIPS served were a combination of chips called Blue Cheese, Dry Aged Ribeye and Billionaire’s Bacon. Sorry, no pictures as they were gobbled up quickly!
Photo from Flatiron Pepper Company
We had an enjoyable dinner this weekend catching up with friends. Dinner, we had an all-day marinated tri-tip steak with Chaka sauce and seasoned with applewood smoke salt with Flatiron BBQ Rub was pounded in the steak on both sides. This rub contains chipotle, ancho, habanero, thyme, toasted onion, smoke ghost peppers, roasted garlic and paprika.
Photo ©Michael Kelly
Then seared at 1500 degrees on the BBQ with the center being medium-rare and the ends more medium. Various side dishes were prepared with this dinner. Included were seasoned and baked potato wedges, fresh green beans that were sautéed with garlic, a French Baggett was sliced and dipped in garlic and kosher salt and then toasted and then finished off with a delicious 7-layer salad that was both artistic and scrumptious.
Photo ©Michael Kelly
Here is the entire meal plated minus the salad that was in a separate salad bowl.
Photo ©Michael Kelly
The meal was enjoyed with a 2012 Entre Nous Cabernet Sauvignon along with the VJB Cellars Aglianico that was a very fine pairing.
The dinner was so enjoyable and the company even better!
Sláinte,
Michael Kelly
Two Excellent Meals in Las Vegas – One With 2022 Faust Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley
Photo by Havana 1957
We arrived in Las Vegas in time for a late lunch at Havana 1957 Cuban cuisine in the Flamingo Hotel. Had one of the most delicious Ceviche dishes ever! It was called the Tropical Ceviche made with fresh Mahi-Mahi, with tomato, aji cachucha, and Leche de Tigre, served over avocado and cucumber, garnished with fresh cilantro, and accompanied by Japanese sweet potato chips.
Photo ©Michael Kelly
Ordered a Spicy Guava Margarita made with Tequila Jose Cuervo Traditional, triple sec, lime juice, syrup Guava Real, tabasco Jalapeño, dehydrated lime with jalapeño and with slices of Jalapeño and lime. Spicy, refreshing, with your mouth trying hard to process if it was sweet or tangy! Note: for the record more than one was had to try to verify the yin-yang taste of this wonderful drink! Also had one of the best waiters, Brendan who was suggestions and service was spot on.
Photo ©Michael Kelly
While in Las Vegas we met with a good friend of over twenty-five years, Rachel Gabato. Enjoyed a drink or two with her. One of the best things in life is meeting up with a longtime friend and picking up the conversation without missing a beat!
Photo ©Michael Kelly
As an aside, since we were in Las Vegas for another friends wedding, we decided to celebrated our 48th wedding anniversary (Nov 19th) a few days early.
Made reservations at Bugsy & Meyer’s Steakhouse. The name is a nod to Benjamin “Bugsy” Siegel and his business partner Meyer Lansky who opened the original Flamingo. The original Flamingo Hotel opened in December 1946. Since we had a late lunch, we decided to go with their prix fixe menu of Caesar salad with aged parmesan cheese, a small filet mignon with house rub and charred at 1200 degrees with a side of steak fries. Ordered a nice bottle of 2022 Faust Cabernet Sauvignon to pair with the meal.
Photo ©Michael Kelly
And
Photo ©Michael Kelly
Finished the meal with a beautiful Crème Brûlée custard with fresh fruit for dessert.
Photo ©Michael Kelly
A great precursor to the evening reception for Nicole and Harrison at Flamingo Hotel for the wedding on Sunday.
Sláinte,
Michael
A Crocker & Starr Evening with two wines – 2019 Casili 12 and 2013 “Stone Place” Cabernet Sauvignon
Photo ©Michael Kelly
The Wines – “Wine is bottled Poetry” – Robert Louis Stevenson
As stated in title, two wines were chosen this evening for the meal.
Photo ©Michael Kelly
*The First Wine – 2019 Crocker & Starr Casili 12. This wine is a blend of 85% Malbec and 15% Cabernet Sauvignon. While having various years of Casili vintages, each year the blend and percentages change. I wanted one with more Malbec percentage to go with the meat this evening. This bottle was placed in the “Eve” decanter by Riedel. This wine on the eyes was deep violet in coloring and even notes of the violet flower wafted into the senses. On the palate blueberries, black cherries were dominate, with mild oak lurking in the background. On the finish a modicum of dark chocolate and vanilla pipe tobacco, counterbalanced by minerality, and a slightly typical smoky element found in the better Malbec wines. This was exactly the flavors needed this evening. The wine came in at 14.4% alcohol. Wine Advocated rated it 94 points. The vintage currently being released is the Casili 15 and lists at $98/per bottle.
*The Second Wine – 2013 Crocker & Starr “Stone Place” Cabernet Sauvignon
Photo ©Michael Kelly
***
Photo ©Michael Kelly
This wine was enjoyed after dinner while enjoying the warm summer weather on the patio. This was another solid choice as “Stone Place” is one of the premiere wines at Crocker & Starr. On the eyes a dense purple coloring filled the glass. On the nose rice and powerful blackberry wafted from the glass. On the palate, a lush and full-bodied fruit of blackberry and black cherry coated the mouth with “happiness”. On the finish a slight minerality and silky-smooth tannins as they seemed to be on siesta, present but not sharp (personal preference). This did make for a great sipping wine without food and came in at 14.4% alcohol. Wine Advocate rated the wine at 95 points and stated it should drink well for 20-25 years. My assessment is that it should be consumed this year or next as it is getting to its peak. The current release for the “Stone Place” is the 2021 and is listed at $195/bottle by Wine Enthusiast.
The Food and Wine Pairing – “Food without wine is a corpse; wine without food is a ghost. United and well matched, they are as body and soul: living partners” – Andre Simon
Photo ©Michael Kelly
Our eldest daughter and husband were in town for dinner Friday night from Arizona. Prepared one of our favorite dishes, Carne Asada. Marinate a flank steak for 24 hours in a delicious sauce. The marinade consisted of cilantro, olive oil, reduced soy sauce, fresh squeezed orange juice, fresh squeezed lime, minced garlic, Serrano peppers, cumin, kosher salt and black pepper. All the ingredients were placed in a blender and then placed in a freezer bag with the steak. Additional marinate was kept separate to drizzle on the medium rare steak slices with fresh cilantro sprinkled and fresh limes squeezed when plated.
Accompanied by Mexican Pasta Salad made with corkscrew pasta, black beans, cherry tomatoes, diced jalapeños, fresh cilantro, yellow corn and cut green onions. The dressing consisted of extra-virgin olive oil, fresh squeezed lime juice, red wine vinegar, minced garlic, sea salt and black pepper. Both recipes were new and tasted exceptionally well and topped off with fresh cilantro. Accompanied by Italian herbedFrench bread. The wine provided bold fruits and enough tannins to engulf the beef spicy notes.
Photo ©Michael Kelly
For dessert, a freshly baked pineapple upside down cake from scratch with the juice added to mix, provided a very moist cake and delicious finish to the evening. The local store had no maraschino cherries!
The Winery
Photo from 2 years ago ©Michael Kelly
Pam Starr is simply a Rock Star. I believe she is one of the elite top 10 winemakers in Napa, but she is also much more than this. Knowing Pam Starr and following her exquisite wines for years, just about all would agree! Her technical pedigree comes from UC Davis in Fermentation Science. She started as an intern at Sonoma Cutrer, Edna Valley Vineyard, then six years at Carmenet Winery and then winemaker for Spottswoode Vineyard. In 1997 she and Charlie Crocker established Crocker & Starr.
Photo from Crocker & Starr website
Charlie Crocker comes from one of California’s oldest families, with his grandfather who was involved in the Central Pacific railroad in the mid 1800’s. His family heritage was a force in California’s development. Charlie also was involved in high tech and ran several companies very successfully. He has always had a keen interest in wine. Charlie in 1971 purchased the Dowdell property in St Helena. Today 85 of the 100 acres are planted in the classical Bordeaux grapes. On their website a detailed chronology is provided and makes a very good read.
The blending of these two personalities as a partnership is as smooth as their wine — seamless and magnificent.
What I enjoy most in getting to know Pam, is her genuineness and friendliness. You can stop by and see her in the vineyards, driving a forklift, punching down tubs of grapes, just about anything and everything. She is immersed in the business of “perfection”. Yet she has time, to sit down and talk, provide a bowl of water for your dogs, and even converse about mundane “non-wine issues”. She is above all else, extremely real and kind. Why wouldn’t you like her wine?
Her enthusiasm spills over into her craft of winemaking skills. I am speaking as a customer and wine club member from this perspective. Since meeting Pam, some twenty years ago, her wines started out at a 10 (scale of 1-10) and have remained at this quality the entire time! No easy feat with droughts, fire and wild temperature swings.
Let’s talk about the wines she produces. First, and why I sought Crocker & Starr initially years ago, was her Cabernet Franc. Each year they produce one of the most consistently solid and best Cabernet Francs in the Valley. The wine always shows a deep purple, with concentrates of black raspberries and tobacco. As some Cab Francs can be “strong”, Crocker & Starr‘s are strong in texture, but surprisingly soft and velvety to drink. They have enough balance of structure, tannin and acid to last 10-15 years without fail.
Today they produce a few Cabernet Sauvignon (RLC, Stone Place, One Post), Cabernet Franc and Casali (blend of Cabernet Franc & Malbec). Also, their white Sauvignon Blanc is superb. One newer addition is Brut Rosé. All her red wines and white wines have consistently made my annual list of “Best Wines Tasted” during the year for the last 15 years! See the links to these reviews:
https://californiawinesandwineries.com/2019/12/28/2011-crocker-starr-stone-place-cabernet-sauvignon/
One of their taglines is “Touch the Vines, Taste the Wines”. When visiting the winery, immersion into the vineyard is a prerequisite. In 2021 Cyrus Hazzard joined the Crocker & Starr team as a Partner & President to continue their esteemed tradition.
Slainte,
Michael Kelly
2011 Shadybrook Estate Cabernet Sauvignon for a 4th of July Dinner
Photo ©Michael Kelly
The Winery and Background
Photo ©Michael Kelly from a previous visit to Shadybrook Estate
2011 was not a great year for Cabernet Sauvignon’s in Napa Valley, or at least many believe it to be true. This wine bucks the trend from the Coombsville sub-AVA in Napa Valley with the help of their stellar winemaker Rudy Zuidema. It has been over two years since I last opened a 2011 Shadybrook Estate Cabernet Sauvignon. Its transformation continues as it has been resting in the cellar. Obviously when purchased it was very good, but some eleven years laying down has made this wine impressive. When originally released, Rudy Zuidema used descriptors as “lush, opulent and finely structured” to open his winemakers notes. This wine used a combination of Clones 337 and 7 of Cabernet Sauvignon grapes. Clone 7 per Rudy was “added density to the nose and palate with black fruit, mocha and a bit of chocolate”. The equal part of Clone 337 contributed “elegance and aromatics lure of the wine with notes of spice, red fruit and cedar”. 6% of Malbec was added to provide background flavors of Asian spices per Rudy.
The Wine – “Wine is bottled poetry” – Robert Louis Stevenson
Photo ©Michael Kelly
This evening on the eyes, a very dark red with just a hint of purple on the edges. The viscosity was medium heavy giving a clue as to what was to come. The bouquet on the nose was aromatic with raspberries being the dominant aroma and with mountain flowers. On the palate a harmonic blend of black fruit, chocolate, red fruit and gentle oak leaped about in the mouth. The finish was tiered and long lasting with a slight “soft and allusive” sweetness. The structure was strong and the tannins silky smooth with no obvious edges.
Upon the first sip, I once again bestowed high marks on this wine. This will make my Annual Best Wines tasted in 2025. The current vintage is 2021 and is listed at $145 and generally in high demand or allocated.
The Food and Wine Pairing – “Food without wine is a corpse; wine without food is a ghost. United and well matched, they are as body and soul: living partners” – Andre Simon
Photo ©Michael Kelly
Pulled this wine out of the cellar to enjoy for the 4th of July with a seasoned ribeye steak. Seared on the outside and barbequed and served medium rare. Accompanied by garlic French bread and homemade potato salad. The potato salad was made the day before to let all the flavors soak into the potatoes. Ingredients included mayonnaise, cider vinegar, yellow mustard, sea salt, black pepper, chopped celery, chopped hard-cooked eggs and cooked bacon. A perfect meal to enjoy the holiday. The wine embraced the steaks handily and steaks soaked up the wine in complete abandonment.
Other stories on Rudy Zuidema & Shadybrook Estate can be found on the https://californiawinesandwineries.com and the story below provides a solid background:
Sláinte,
Michael
https://californiawinesandwineries.com
https://www.shadybrookestate.com/
2021 Gracianna Cabernet Sauvignon, Stagecoach Vineyard, Napa Valley
Background
Photo ©Michael Kelly
It seemed only appropriated to start off Memorial weekend thinking of those who sacrificed so much for all of us. Gracianna meaning giving thanks and being grateful.
The Winery
Photo from Gracianna website
The name Gracianna is for Trini Amador III’s (owner) great grandmother (Gracianna) and they wanted to incorporate all they had to be grateful for and show their gratitude. Even on the back of the bottle, it reads “Gracianna is for those who have something to be grateful for”. The winery is set next to the Russian River on the well know “Miracle Mile” home of some of the best Pinots just outside of Healdsburg. The “Miracle Mile” is the confluence of a tectonic age, alluvial soils left by a wandering river, water flowing off the Sonoma Mountain range which carried with it eroded volcanic material–all of these factors created soil with large amounts of clay in the central portion of the Russian River Valley appellation.
Photo from Gracianna website
Gracianna produces several thousand cases per year of which 70% is for various Pinot’s. The balance of production is for Zinfandel, Sauvignon Blanc, Chardonnay, Merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon and Sparkling Brut Rosé – Blush Cuvée. All their Pinot’s are produced in the Burgundian style with French barrels. They use clones 667 and 777 for their Pinot’s in the vineyard and then blend the two. The wine making is a “family affair” with all giving “gratitude” for the fruit of the vineyard.
The Wine – “Wine is bottled Poetry” – Robert Louis Stevenson
Those familiar with Napa Valley are no stranger to Stagecoach Vineyards which ranges from 1,100 to 1,750 feet elevation. At this elevation the fog is typically lower providing the fruit a longer ripening season. More time on the vine results in bold, ripe fruit providing a robust experience.
Photo ©Michael Kelly
The wine is 100% Cabernet Sauvignon, with aging in 100% French oak barrels. Only 95 cases were produced and 15.2% alcohol. Priced at $128/bottle and currently as of this writing is on sale (check their website). This wine won a Gold Medal at the 2024 SF Chronicle Competition, a Gold Medal at the 2024 Sommeliers Choice Awards, Silver Medal at the Press Democrat North Coast Challenge and a Silver Medal at the 2024 Los Angeles Invitational Wine Challenge.
First on the eyes and deep dark hue of red, almost black hints of the lushness to follow. On the nose blackberries and blueberries waft gently into the senses. Once on the palate the bright and “bursting flavors” of the dark fruits of black cherries, blackberries and blueberries are dominant. Secondary flavors and mid-palate provide hints of dark roasted coffee and vanilla. On the finish, the tannins start off strong and bold but are tamed down with soft vanilla residual notes, making this a complex and delightful wine concluding each sip with finesse and grace.
Photo ©Michael Kelly
I am thankful that this wine is now on my annual list of Best Wines Tasted for 2025! Only 2-3% of the approximate 1800 wines tasted yearly make this list that is published at years end.
The Food and Wine Pairing – “Food without wine is a corpse; wine without food is a ghost. United and well matched, they are as body and soul: living partners” – Andre Simon
Photo ©Michael Kelly
Pulled this wine specifically for this seared filet mignon at 1500 degrees this evening and served medium rare. Accompanied by a Yukon Gold potato and sauteed asparagus. Also served for an unusual dessert was a salad of halved cherry tomatoes with fresh basil, mozzarella cheese, sea salt, pepper and extra virgin olive oil. Mixed in were a few semi-dried tomatoes from Italy that were mixed in sunflower oil, salt, sugar, parsley leaves, powered garlic and oregano leaves. This made for a perfect conclusion to the meal.
Photo ©Michael Kelly
An excellent food and wine pairing this evening leaving the dinner table completely full and appreciating fine food and wine.
Sláinte,
Michael