Italian wines
A Wonderful Tasting at Vinum55 with Caiarossa and Château Giscours

Last evening a rare and appreciated treat at Vinum55 in Scottsdale with two wineries, one in Italy and one in France, owned by the same family being presented and tasted. While only five exquisite wines were served due to the rarity and price points, each were remarkable. Pricing for the wines ranged from $85 to $140/bottle. It was the only session I attended where all the wines were given my higher scores across the board.

Photo ©Michael Kelly
After a brief introduction by Shelly Fitzgerald of Vinum55 (on the right) , she turned the presentation and tasting over to Pauline Wlodarzyck from the winery.

Caiarossa was founded in 1998, and AJ Family Domaines acquired the estate in 2004. The land is biodynamic farmed with similar winemaking practices in place. The property is in Tuscany between Volterra and Ceche just outside Riparbella. The estate receives cool breezes off the sea, and the vineyards are located up on the hillsides. The land is worked by hand due to the steep sloped vineyards.

Now with the background information in hand, we commenced the tasting!

Photo ©Michael Kelly
We started out the evening with 2022 Caiarossa, a blend of Cabernet Franc, Syrah, Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Petit Verdot, Sangiovese and Grenache. Both this one and next were smooth, lively and provided an airy freshness. In the glass, both wines were radiant and bright.

Photo ©Michael Kelly
The second wine was a 2017 Caiarossa that was a warm/hot year in Italy producing ripe fruits tasted of Plum and red fruits. A similar blend to the first with percentages varying and this substituting Alicante Bouschet instead of Grenache. This provided on the palate a more earthy with slightly more tannins and acidity than the 2022. A soft note of sweetness was noted on the finish.

Picture from http://www.TripAdvisor.comTripadvisor
We then moved on to three of Château Giscours with its tasting room and guest rooms building dating back to the 1790’s. This is located on the left bank of Bordeaux in the town of Labarde, in the Margaux appellation of the Médoc, Bordeaux, France. The refurbished winery was built using gravity fed principles for winemaking and even included feng shui concepts into the architecture. Their 2025 was named Wine of the Year by Wine Spectator. The estate is 400 acres with no irrigation.
Started off with the 2022 Château Giscours with lively fruit being noted in the glass. On the eyes this received a noted “Excellence” with the bright coloring.

Photo ©Michael Kelly
The next wine was the 2020 Château Giscours that on the eyes was crisp, semi-transparent made with 56% Cabernet Sauvignon and 44% Merlot fermented in both stainless steel and concrete tanks. The wine was aged in 50% French Oak barrels for 12-15 months. This produced an elegant and voluptuous wine with energetic berries abounding on the palate. This wine received scores all in the mid 90’s by a host of critics. This received my highest rating during the tasting.

Photo ©Michael Kelly
A very special treat of the 2008 Château Giscours was offered. This wine on the nose had both an earthy and barnyard character, with tastes of tobacco and layers of enjoyment. The finish provided smooth and silky tannins. I noticed just a hint of copper on the edges but beyond enjoyable to the last sip!

Photo ©Michael Kelly
A great tasting by any standard and very much appreciated by those attending. A big hearty thanks to Pauline and Vinum55 for holding this event.
Sláinte,
Michael Kelly
https://californiawinesandwineries.com
2022 Selvagrossa “Poveriano” Cabernet Franc from Italy

Background
Met the owner and distributor for Vinity Wine Company in Emeryville, California at CabFranc-a-Palooza in June, 2025. They were pouring a couple of Cabernet Franc wines from Italy. I have been intrigued by Cabernet Franc wines from Italy for the last few years since Daryl Corti won the Best of Show for his wine from Italy from both the Professional & People’s Choice Judges in 2023 at the International Cabernet Franc Competition.
The Wine – “Wine is bottled Poetry” – Robert Louis Stevenson

Photo ©Michael Kelly
This wine comes from the Marche region in Central Italy (in red on the map below), located on the Adriatic coast. The vineyards are located 12 km east of the coast in the hills of Pesaro at an elevation of 325 feet. The wine spent 14 months in French barriques being 50% new and 50% neutral. Additionally the wine spent six months in bottle before being released. The alcohol level was 13.5%.

The wine on the eyes was cavernously deep red with medium-heavy viscosity. On the nose, lush red and black fruits rose to greet the imbiber. Present were a modicum of pyrazines (green bell pepper) and spices. On the palate, a rustic old world Cabernet Franc was immediately noticeable with dark cherry flavors, earthy minerality and complex structure. The finish was surprisingly smooth with silky soft tannins and very well balanced.
The Food and Wine Pairing – “Food without wine is a corpse; wine without food is a ghost. United and well matched, they are as body and soul: living partners” – Andre Simon

Photo ©Michael Kelly
Went to the Wine Steward in Pleasanton, California and spoke with Jim Denham looking for a recommendation for dinner with either a Nero d’ Avola or Montepulciano d’ Abruzzo. He alternatively suggested this wine for a chicken cacciatore meal this evening at a good friend’s home in Livermore, California. Cacciatore is a rustic Italian dish that has braised chicken in a flavorful tomato sauce with vegetable and herbs. Accompanied by a fresh salad. This wine provided fruit flavors surrounding each morsel consumed this evening! Very nice food and wine pairing.
The dessert was a homemade crust and strawberry pie that was spectacular.

Photo ©Michael Kelly
And if this wasn’t decadent enough, freshly whipped cream crowned this delicious slice!

Photo ©Michael Kelly
The only thing better than this gorgeous wine and delicious food was catching up with good friends with conversations both lighthearted and heart-felt. Thanks, Gomes, for a wonderful evening!
Sláinte,
Michael Kelly































